Excuse Me


Excuse Me 3D frame

Andrew MacMillen's Level 3 Rocket

Flight 1

Saturday May 26, 2007 at FITS 2007.

Summary: Failure...

Dimensions: 12' x 5.5", 14.5" span
Dry weight: 25 lb
Tanked pad weight: 38 lb
Spent weight: 32 lb
Preheater: immediate ignition
Ignition: less than 2 seconds
Liftoff: quick acceleration
Boost: 7.5 sec burn, 5 sec blowdown
Coast: very slow left roll
Drogue deployment: didn't see, 2 charges fired, airframe separated
Drogue descent: fast & flopping all over
Main deployment: 1000' charge didn't clear nosecone, 800' charge did; nose cone & its' harness executed a 1/2 overhand knot through the lower upper airframe harness; knot prevented main bundle from opening
Landing: came in without main @ ~75 fps, upper end of lower airframe impacted first in soft dirt
Damage: upper end of lower airframe mushroomed back to top of motor; many nosecone dings; all easily reparable
Max acceleration: 162 ft/sec/sec; 5.0 G
Max speed: 663 ft/sec; Mach 0.6
Altitude: 
Missileworks RRC2X-40K: 8118'
GWiz MC barometric: 7973'
GWiz MC accelerometer: 8109'

Failure Analysis:

  • NC harness did a half over-hand knot through the body harness, knotting the main bundle closed
  • it did so because I chose to go drogue-less at the last minute, and the pieces were flapping all over
  • I went drogue-less because I couldn't get the drogue & harnesses to fit at the away cell (I couldn't prep in camp & transport a 12.5' load) the same way I had at home
  • the fit didn't work because I chose to use the 1/2" Kevlar, which as was so thoroughly pointed out, is 100X or more overkill
  • the end result is that I'll fix the dings, repair the forward end of the booster, switch to 1/4" Kevlar plus something TBD to inhibit zippers (short pieces of 2" nylon?) and try again with my 2nd reload

Photos:

M 'n M
M 'n M<
Photo courtesy of &
©2007 Brad Wright
Me 'n Excuse Me
Me 'n Excuse Me
Photo ©2007
Andrew MacMillen
Launch!
Launch!
Photo courtesy of &
©2007 Bill Clugston
Clean flame
Clean flame
Photo courtesy of &
©2007 Bill Clugston

Multimedia:

Slideshow (3.8MB MOV)
Excuse Me slideshow
Video (1.3MB WMV)
Excuse Me video
Photos & video courtesy of & ©2007 Rockets Magazine

Gwiz data:

Summary
Summary
Overlay
Overlay
Overlay detail
Overlay detail
Acceleration
Acceleration
Acceleration detail
Acceleration detail
Gwiz vs. TMT *
Gwiz vs. TMT
* F=MA; neglects drag but includes decrementing mass

RockSim projected an altitude around 12K' (even with a finished weight mass override) whereas the flight only achieved 8K'. The much lower thrust fully explains this, but since the supply tank was near optimal pressure, I'm uncertain why the flight & impulse was so much lower than expected.


Motor:

Ratt M900 parts
Ratt M900 parts
M900 hybrid grain
M900 hybrid grain
Grain burn through
Grain burn through
Inside grain
Inside grain
Inside grain detail
Inside grain detail
 

The grain was burned through at the phenolic pre-combustion chamber shoulder after the flight. Since the case is un-damaged, this most likely occured during the low pressure & heat blow-down phase.

After discussing this with Rattworks, I discovered that my X-injector is a beta release version that only has 2 crossing slots, so the nitrous is directed mostly sideways and impinges on the grain exactly at the pre-combustion chamber shoulder. The release version injector has both slots and a hole in the tip to direct some of the nitrous down the chamber. An upgrade will solve this problem, and hopefully improve the thrust.


FITS 2007 Sunset
FITS 2007 Sunset
Photo courtesy of & ©2007 Kathy Woodford

Top